Carrie (1976)
Bullying is one of the most toxic, irrevocably damaging problems prevalent in society. It is a social ill that has existed probably since the beginning of time, and has shown absolutely no signs of slowing down or reaching anything in the way of a legitimate, tangible resolution. In a way, it's been almost accepted and written off as a natural -- but no less toxic -- aspect of the human condition. Like the old saying goes, hurt people hurt people, and there will always be someone who desires to take their pain and fury out on someone else in a futile attempt to alleviate their own internal suffering. Children bully their fellow classmates in school, usually middle and high, and there are even grown-ups who validate the concept that just because you're older doesn't necessarily mean you're wiser.
Look at incidents like Columbine. Two high school seniors were presumably bullied to such an extent that they felt the only way they could vent those building feelings of anger, resentment, and sadness was by showing up to school one day with shotguns and mowing down anyone who had ever caused them to suffer, in addition to multiple other people whose only mistake was being in the wrong place at the wrong time.
In most cases, however, the victims of bullying don't resolve to get revenge on their tormentors, they simply take their own life. In 2003, Ryan Halligan, a thirteen-year-old boy, once so full of life and energy, with musical and acting talent, hanged himself in his bathroom after being bullied both in school and online by a horde of classmates after one classmate spread a false rumor that Ryan was gay. In 2010, Phoebe Prince, a stunning fifteen-year-old who had recently relocated from Ireland to an American school, hanged herself in her apartment stairwell after enduring over a months' worth of insufferable torment from five classmates who wanted to punish her for having sexual relations with two (unbeknownst to her) unavailable men.
If there is one person who knows what it feels like to be bullied day in and day out, taunted in the hallways of their school, snickered at behind their back, only to come home and find themselves subjected to even more severe, undeserved punishment, it's Carrie White.
It's a normal day like any other in Chamberlain, Maine. It's April or May, and the students at Bates High School are looking forward to the approaching prom that will be taking place in their gym the following Friday. But first, it's time for gym class. This is not a co-ed class, but rather one that consists exclusively of female students. They're playing a competitive game of volleyball outside, orchestrated by their authoritative teacher, Miss Collins (Betty Buckley). Everyone seems to be enjoying themselves, spiking the ball back and forth, eager to win but having fun either way. Except for the outlier in the back, sixteen-year-old Carrie White (Sissy Spacek), who appears to be somewhat intimidated by the ball, backing up further, not displaying much energy. "Hit it to Carrie, she'll blow it," one girl crudely shouts. "Don't blow it, Carrie, hit it!" demands another player. But sure enough, once the ball comes flying at her face, Carrie flinches and misses. The whistle blows. Game over. All the girls are almost comically infuriated as they storm past Carrie, who just stands there on the court looking humiliated, her hands intermingled behind her back, trying to muster a guilty smile, only to have her head smacked with a baseball cap by Norma Watson (P.J. Soles). As they all make their way to the showers, one girl stops and turns around, the most popular girl at Bates who seems to have it out for Carrie the most, Chris Hargensen (Nancy Allen), and tells the defenseless teen, "You eat shit!"
Editor Paul Hirsch abruptly cuts to the interior of the girls' locker room, where cinematographer Mario Tosi treats the male audience to an unrestricted tour. The young women have all just gotten out of the shower and are drying themselves off and getting dressed, socializing with one another as they do so. As Seth Rogen and Katherine Heigl enthusiastically point out in Knocked Up, there is an eye-opening display of nudity during these opening credits. Set to the beautiful, angelic music of Pino Donaggio, and filmed in entrancing slow motion by Hirsch, Tosi glides his camera past the gallery of partially clothed and fully naked young women as they brush their hair, laugh, and whip each other with towels. Under the dazzling direction of Brian De Palma, Tosi captures their beauty, their youth, their carefree love to be young and beautiful. While some of the actresses have their bras and panties on, others, such as Allen, demonstrate the remarkable confidence and comfortability to expose themselves from top to bottom for the camera, revealing their breasts and vaginas without any efforts made to shield them or speed by them at a faster pace. While this nudity might have been seen as more liberating had a woman been working behind the camera, De Palma is still more celebratory than exploitative, granting these women the opportunity to feel comfortable in their own bodies, and not feel ashamed to show them off freely as though the camera were not there. It's both beautiful and erotic all at once.
But there's still one girl left in the shower, and that's of course Carrie. She is standing under the showerhead, scrubbing her body with soap and allowing the water to pour peacefully over her face. De Palma films this simple act in the most singularly sensual fashion, zooming in on Spacek and observing in slow motion as she moves her hands all over her body, her chest, her stomach, her legs. She caresses her breasts, rubs the bar of soap against her cheeks, aiming her head upward while keeping her eyes closed. Even though all she's doing is showering, the way De Palma directs her almost makes it seem as though she's masturbating, exploring her body for the first time in her life, basking in the pleasure of making physical contact with her own flesh. It's apparent no one else has touched her body thus far.
With her hands between her legs, the soap dripping down like semen, something else begins to cascade from her privates. A red liquid. Carrie looks down and sees it pouring down onto the floor, seeping through her fingers. A look of concern furrows her brow, and De Palma captures this anxiety through a close-up of Spacek's eyes. The sounds of laughter echo throughout the locker room, a taunting contrast to Carrie's terror. She speedwalks to her fellow classmates and grabs onto them, tearfully pleading for their help, unintentionally getting her blood on them, but her tears and screams are met with further derision and sadism. Recognizing that she's having her first period and doesn't understand what it is, all of the girls, led by Chris, begin laughing at Carrie and pelting her with tampons, sanitary napkins, and toilet paper. Wide-eyed with fear and desperation, Carrie backs up into a wall and descends to the floor, the girls continuing to shower her under feminine hygiene products and gleefully chanting, "Plug it up."
Coming to the poor, inexperienced teen's rescue is Miss Collins, who initially doesn't understand why Carrie is so horrified by her own period, and demands that she clean herself up and take care of herself. Carrie breaks down crying in Miss Collins' arms, sobbing like a child. Chris and Norma giggle uncontrollably to themselves, and Miss Collins orders them to leave, realizing that Carrie genuinely believes she's dying. The only member of the group who instantly feels sorry for what she's participated in is Sue Snell (Amy Irving), and in an effort to make amends, she asks her boyfriend, Tommy Ross (William Katt), a track athlete, to take Carrie to the prom instead of her, a deeply surprising and unpleasant request that the good-natured Tommy reluctantly agrees to after some deliberation (and silent treatment).
At home, Carrie's life is no better than at Bates. In fact, it's arguably worse. While I don't have much personal experience in school bullying, I would imagine that most students, after being harassed by their ignorant peers, are permitted to return home every day and be greeted with love, warmth, and respect by their own families. Such is not the reality for Carrie, who has to come home every day to a deranged fundamentalist mother named Margaret (Piper Laurie), who chastises, physically abuses, and on several occasions enslaves her own daughter in a closet to pray and reflect on her perceived sins. After receiving a phone call from Miss Collins about Carrie's bloody episode in the shower, Margaret hits her over the head with her Bible and accuses her of committing the "sin" of lustful thoughts and sexual intercourse. Clearly, Margaret had never taught Carrie about menstruation, in fear of her growing into a woman, and this is what confused her into believing the blood seeping from her represented death.
Miss Collins' idea for punishing the girls who participated in the locker room attack is three days' suspension and refusal of their prom tickets. However, because the office decides they will have one week's detention, she manages to personalize that detention via subjecting them to a vigorous workout every day after school on the athletic field. Chris, deciding that she's too good and too darn popular to partake in such a cruel treatment (even though she has no problem dishing out such a treatment to Carrie), throws a fit and gets herself kicked out of the prom. Because she's the type of person who refuses to take accountability for her actions and, in her mind, believes it's always someone else's fault, Chris conspires with her easily manipulated boyfriend, Billy Nolan (John Travolta), to enact vengeance on Carrie, finding a way to humiliate her in the worst way imaginable.
Unfortunately for Chris and everyone else at Bates High, Carrie is no ordinary teenager. Sure, she's an outcast not much different from any other: she wears outdated clothing forced upon her by her religious mother, doesn't have any friends, mopes around school with her hair draped in front of her face, sits in the back of her English class (and probably every other class), and rarely lets her voice be heard. But after a lightbulb mysteriously breaks in the locker room during her freakout, an ash tray flips over and shatters on the floor when she becomes irritated at having her name repeatedly mispronounced by the ridiculously forgetful principal, and her bedroom mirror cracks into pieces before rearranging itself, Carrie begins reading up on miracles and comes to the realization that she was born with telekinesis, a supernatural ability to move and cause changes to objects by force of the mind, a power that has just been dormant for the first fifteen years of her life.
Based on the fourth written and first published novel of the same name by acclaimed horror author, Stephen King, Carrie is a supremely effective -- and at times darkly amusing -- amalgamation of supernatural horror, coming-of-age drama, high school comedy, and profoundly tragic character study, brought to life by a brilliantly chosen cast of enthusiastic, dedicated actors and a visionary director with loads of personality.
One of the primary ingredients that differentiates Carrie from so many other horror films is its restraint. To put it more specifically, Lawrence D. Cohen, who adapted the screenplay from King's novel, reserves the actual, supernatural horror of the story for the legendary climax, spending the preceding hour and fifteen minutes developing his tragic protagonist from a meek, timid, insecure victim into a joyful, more confident, assertive young woman ready to take control of her newfound power and her life as a whole. Unlike more traditional horror villains who commit heinous acts of violence throughout their entire movies, Carrie White stands out from the pack as one of the most well-rounded, fully dimensional, and thoroughly sympathetic anti-heroes. Even after she's pushed over the edge and uses her gift for evil, to unleash every ounce of suppressed fury that's been growing inside her like a tumor, we remain firmly on Carrie's side because we recognize that, while mass murder is never an excuse, she's still a victim of the cruelty that's been pummeling her for the majority of her life. Carrie is not a monster, but she's also not entirely a victim by the end of the film, either. At heart, she's a normal, bruised human being in need of some compassion, empathy, and friendship -- and sadly, so few people are willing to spare her those essentials.
Since 1976 when this original motion picture was unveiled for the world to witness, there have been two more adaptations of the 1974 text starring Angela Bettis and Chloe Grace Moretz, respectively. Few would argue that the actress most people associate with the eponymous role of Carrie White is Sissy Spacek, and for good reason. She is utterly tremendous. Spacek was 26 years old when she made this movie, approximately a decade older than the character she was assigned, and yet she flawlessly embodies the social awkwardness and isolation of an adolescent who's never been on a single date, never had a single person to call a "friend", and never had the latitude to evolve into her own person. For that matter, Spacek was an instance of perfect casting because Carrie is, after all, a young woman enslaved in a state of permanent childhood, forbidden from experiencing the tribulations and pleasures of womanhood. Therefore, it's fitting that a 26-year-old adult was selected to play this particular 16-year-old senior. From a purely physical perspective, Spacek has a youthful appearance that suits Carrie beautifully, her face covered in freckles, her long, flat, dirty blonde hair hanging over her cheeks and down her back, her voice edged with a childlike sweetness. Spacek's body language is exquisite, hanging her head in discomfort and holding her books close to her chest when Tommy Ross approaches her out of nowhere in the library.
The event that triggers the most pronounced transition in Carrie's personality is Tommy inviting her to the prom. At first she's terrified and astonished. Why would the most handsome, popular guy in the senior class just wake up one morning and decide to ask Carrie White, of all people, to the prom? Like a frightened child, her first instinct is to run away from the situation, literally, and seclude herself on a bench beside her school's bathroom. It's during this moment of self-doubt that Cohen and De Palma give Carrie its most heartfelt scene. Miss Collins comes across Carrie sitting by herself with her head down and sits beside her, asking what's the matter. Carrie confides that she's been invited to prom by Tommy, and the only emotion Miss Collins can provide is pure empathetic happiness. "I know who he goes around with," states Carrie, wiser than she appears. "They're trying to trick me again, I know." When Miss Collins suggests that he might have meant it, Carrie immediately shakes her head, prompting the warmhearted teacher to wrap her arms around Carrie and take her into the bathroom. She stands her in front of a mirror and tells her to look at herself, emphasizing her attractive features and urging her to adopt a more respectful attitude toward herself. Betty Buckley paints a beautiful portrait of the type of teacher every child should be lucky enough to have at at least one point in their life. Warm, caring, soft-spoken, and a no-nonsense disciplinarian to anyone who hurts another human being for no reason, Miss Collins is an absolute angel, the first true friend in Carrie's life who essentially gives her the self-esteem she never had.
Another beautifully written and delivered moment between Carrie and Miss Collins occurs at the prom. Once Tommy graciously excuses himself from their table, Miss Collins takes his seat across from Carrie and shares a story from her own senior prom. Her date was the captain of the basketball team and was 6 feet 7 inches tall, so in order to make their kiss goodnight "less awkward", she bought a pair of 3-inch spike heels. Due to his pick-up truck breaking down, they had to walk the last half-mile to prom, resulting in blisters on her feet. When they finally arrived, there was no chance for them on the dance floor, so they just sat and talked the entire night, which Miss Collins summarizes as "magic."
In preparation for her first social event, Carrie goes all out, trying on different lipsticks, applying a curl to her customarily flat, mousy hair, and sewing herself a pink dress, unafraid to expose her cleavage. Spacek makes her transformation from a shrinking violet to a self-assured swan so thoroughly believable it's practically imperceptible. It doesn't feel like two different characters being played by the same actress; it registers more as one individual seizing her opportunity to become the person she's always dreamt of being, had her mother and classmates not robbed it from her. While applying eye makeup in her bedroom before Tommy arrives to pick her up, Margaret implores Carrie to take off the dress and stay home with her, where they can pray together for forgiveness, but Carrie refuses, even using her telekinesis to throw her mother down onto her bed. "Just sit there, Mama, and don't say a word until I'm gone!" For the first time in her life, Carrie is standing up to her mother, refusing to be her prisoner or live by her traditional, gender-restrictive worldview any longer. Spacek exerts a quiet authority in these scenes, and when the inevitable moment comes when she's elected prom queen, walking between a crowd of cheering, clapping attendees and standing on stage facing all of her classmates and teachers, she flashes the most radiant smile. Tears of joy well in her eyes. Her joy is palpable, and that only makes the comedown even more gutting.
Carrie feels like a more realistic and grounded character than Margaret, in no small part thanks to the humanizing manner in which Spacek plays her, but Piper Laurie invests her fanatical mother with a theatrical intensity that's nothing short of spellbinding. At the 1977 Academy Awards, when the voters still felt a sense of respect for the horror genre, both Spacek and Laurie were acknowledged for their efforts in Carrie with nominations for Best Actress (Spacek) and Best Supporting Actress (Laurie). While neither walked away with a statue, I'm grateful both ladies were seen as deserving. The relationship between Carrie and Margaret sits at the forefront of the narrative, their power dynamic shifting constantly as each confused, lonely woman struggles for the upper hand. Margaret weaponizes her faith to control Carrie, instilling in her a fear of heterosexual relationships and a belief that sex will condemn her to hell. Piper Laurie recites multiple passages from the Bible with the fervor of a true, brainwashed believer. Margaret is, in fact, so deranged and enamored with Jesus that when Laurie first read the script, she interpreted the genre as comedy, bursting out laughing when she tried to read her lines with a straight face. De Palma had to pull her aside on at least one occasion to remind her they're dealing with a horror movie, but Laurie remained steadfast in her belief that no, this is a comedy. A satire on organized religion. It just has to be. Well, as incorrect as that interpretation may have been, and boy, is she lucky Brian didn't fire her right there on the spot for her mockery of Cohen's script, Laurie utilized that reading to inform her portrayal of Margaret, delivering a delightfully over-the-top performance that proudly lays waste to restraint, subtlety, or introspection. Coming from the lips of a less zealous or devoted actress, lines such as "Oh, Lord, help this sinning woman see the sin of her days and ways" and "Thou shall not suffer witch to live" would've come across as laughable. With Laurie chewing them up and spitting them out like popcorn kernels, Margaret has solidified a firm place for herself in the hall of fame of horror's most memorable mothers. And the reveal of the nature of Carrie's conception and the explanation behind Margaret's loathing of sex is distressingly revealing.
Brian De Palma does wonders with Lawrence Cohen's screenplay, which, as superbly written as it is on the page, simply wouldn't have achieved the level of personality it has without the director's input. What impresses me the most about De Palma's direction is he takes the dark, real-world themes embedded into the script -- bullying, religious fanaticism, the need for human interaction, the desire to grow comfortably into one's own skin -- and leavens them with a buoyant, frequently campy tone without ever sacrificing the seriousness of the story or the heartbreaking tragedy of his protagonist's life. For example, the scene where Tommy goes shopping for a tuxedo with his best friends, Freddy "The Beak" Holt (Doug Cox) and George Dawson (Harry Gold), is downright comedic in its editing and behavior. George and Beak argue back and forth about the latter's lack of cooperation in choosing a tuxedo. George is all hyped up and playfully irritable, telling Beak that, for ten bucks, he can rent himself a tuxedo, but the nonchalant, stubborn Beak insists he doesn't have a "tuxedo body." At one point during their argument, De Palma replays two of their previous lines in fast motion, making their voices sound like high-pitched chipmunks. His pacing is extraordinarily fast, guiding Paul Hirsch to cut through scenes with such breathtaking rapidity that nothing ever feels like filler, buying time until the climactic prom massacre. At the same time, they resist the temptation to cheat us out of sufficient time to bond with the colorful characters.
In addition to slow motion, a quirky sense of humor, and fast editing, De Palma uses a variety of music to submerge us into the mindset of Carrie White. Pino Donaggio creates pieces that are excessively dramatic, heartwarming, hopeful, fairytale-like, and suspenseful. While some of the music is a bit overused, it's always emotionally riveting to listen to, and De Palma selects each melody precisely to capture whatever mood Carrie is experiencing at any given time.
The special effects are pretty low-key. There's nothing extraordinarily good or bad about them, save a car crash that takes place late in the film, endured by the lead instigators of the prom prank; De Palma stages the disaster with brutal realism, cutting between interior shots of the car to show the victims flipping over and screaming, and exterior shots of the car flipping over and finally exploding. There's no gore to speak of, but the swift, bruising impact of this kill delivers the comeuppance for which we've been patiently salivating. A scene where Carrie is staring at herself in her bedroom mirror becomes the first time when she experiments with her ability, and the sight of the mirror trembling looks a little phony. This is also one of two occasions when De Palma somewhat brazenly rips off Bernard Herrmann's shower theme in Psycho. The other sequence is when Carrie exposes her telekinesis to Margaret for the first time in the kitchen to assert her dominance, closing all of the windows simultaneously. For as animated and inspired as his direction is throughout, De Palma does make a few bizarre choices here and there. If he were making a parody of Alfred Hitchcock's thriller, the music choice would be more appropriate, but Carrie features no discernible connection, rendering his use strangely out of place.
I'll also never understand his decision to mask the voice of his own nephew, Cameron, with that of Betty Buckley in the scene where Carrie is walking home from school, and the little boy played by Cameron rides past on his bike chanting, "Creepy Carrie, Creepy Carrie, ha ha ha," before being knocked telekinetically to the ground. What was wrong with his own voice? He's clearly a preadolescent boy, so what on earth was Brian thinking when he decided to replace it with the voice of a 28-year-old woman? Granted, Betty does have the voice of a bratty child, but a distinctly female bratty child. So it sounds like a little girl's voice is emanating from Cameron's mouth. Did Brian secretly want a young girl to play this small role, but didn't want to hurt the feelings of his little nephew? If that's the case, and I were Cameron, I would feel more offended that my uncle allowed me to do a scene in his movie, only to cut out my own voice in post-production and make me sound like a little girl. Just my two cents.
This may technically be more of a blunder in the script than Brian's direction, but since he's the director and therefore has the final word in what's adapted from the script and what's cut out, he must accept some of the blame for the Carrie/Cassie absurdity. Everyone who has seen Carrie must automatically know what I'm referring to. After her attack in the locker room, Carrie is summoned into Principal Morton's (Stefan Gierasch) office, where he proceeds to repeatedly call her "Cassie" even after Miss Collins corrects him twice. Rather than summarize the stupidity on display in this scene, I think it would be better to quote it without any accusation of exaggeration on my part.
- Principal Morton: (over the intercom) Miss Finch, will you send in Cassie Wright?
- Miss Collins: It's Carrie White.
- (Carrie enters)
- Principal Morton: Come in, Cassie.
- Miss Collins: Carrie.
- Principal Morton: Miss Finch, would you bring in a dismissal slip? (to Carrie) I thought you might take the rest of the day and go home, take care of yourself, Cassie.
Comments
Post a Comment